| TO: | Freedom of Information Commission |
| FROM: | Mary E. Schwind |
| RE: | Minutes of the Commission’s regular meeting of June 13, 2012 - as amended and corrected at the Commission meeting of June 27, 2012 |
| DATE: | June 28, 2012 |
A regular meeting of the Freedom of Information Commission was held on June 13, 2012, in the Freedom of Information Hearing Room, 18-20 Trinity Street, Hartford, Connecticut. The meeting convened at 2:15 p.m. with the following Commissioners present:
Commissioner Norma E. Riess, presiding
Commissioner Sherman D. London
Commissioner Owen P. Eagan
Commissioner Amy J. LiVolsi
Commissioner Jay Shaw (participated via speakerphone)
Commissioner Jonathan Einhorn
Commissioner Matthew Streeter
Commissioner Sherman D. London
Commissioner Owen P. Eagan
Commissioner Amy J. LiVolsi
Commissioner Jay Shaw (participated via speakerphone)
Commissioner Jonathan Einhorn
Commissioner Matthew Streeter
Colleen M. Murphy, Mary E. Schwind, Victor R. Perpetua, Tracie C. Brown, Kathleen K. Ross, Valicia D. Harmon, Paula S. Pearlman, Cindy Cannata and Thomas A. Hennick.
Those in attendance were informed that the Commission does not ordinarily record the remarks made at its meetings, but will do so on request.
|
Ira Alston v. Chief, Police Department, City of New Haven; and Police Department, City of New Haven |
Ira Alston participated via speakerphone. Attorney Kathleen Foster appeared on behalf of the respondents. The Commissioners unanimously voted to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report. The proceedings were recorded digitally.
|
Gaylord Salters v. Chief, Police Department, City of New Haven; Police Department, City of New Haven; Commissioner, State of Connecticut, Department of Correction; and State of Connecticut, Department of Correction |
Gaylord Salters participated via speakerphone. Attorney Kathleen Foster appeared on behalf of the New Haven respondents. Attorney Nancy Kase O’Brasky appeared on behalf of the Department of Correction respondents. The Commissioners unanimously voted to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report. The proceedings were recorded digitally.
|
Latone James v. Chief, Police Department, City of Waterbury; Police Department, City of Waterbury; Commissioner, State of Connecticut, Department of Correction; and State of Connecticut, Department of Correction |
Latone James participated via speakerphone. Attorney Kevin Daly appeared on behalf of the Waterbury respondents. Attorney James Neil appeared on behalf of the
Department of Correction respondents. The Commissioners unanimously voted to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report. The proceedings were recorded digitally.
Department of Correction respondents. The Commissioners unanimously voted to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report. The proceedings were recorded digitally.
|
Terry Wright v. Superintendent, Granby Public Schools; Board of Education, Granby Public Schools; and Granby Public Schools |
Terry Wright appeared on his own behalf. Attorney Jessica Ritter appeared on behalf of the respondents. The Commissioners unanimously voted to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report. The proceedings were recorded digitally.
|
Elisabeth Seieroe Maurer v. Office of Corporation Counsel, City of Danbury; and City of Danbury |
Elisabeth Seieroe Maurer appeared on her own behalf. Attorney Johanna Zelman appeared on behalf of the respondents. Attorney Eric Chester appeared on behalf of the intervenor Danbury Firefighters Union, Local 801. Kenneth Ackell, an intervenor, appeared on his own behalf. The Commissioners voted, 6-0, to amend the Hearing Officer’s Report. The Commissioners voted, 6-0, to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report as amended.* Commissioner Shaw did not participate in this matter. Commissioner London asked that the record reflect the stellar effort by Attorney Paula S. Pearlman in reviewing numerous in camera records in connection with this matter.
|
R. John Farnham v. Town Manager, Town of Rocky Hill; and Town of Rocky Hill |
The Commissioners unanimously voted to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report.
|
Robert Cushman v. Chief, Police Department, City of New London; and Police Department, City of New London |
The Commissioners unanimously voted to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report.
|
Robert Cushman v. Chief, Police Department, City of New London; and Police Department, City of New London |
The Commissioners unanimously voted to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report.
|
George Schober v. Janet Tyler, Superintendent, Lebanon Public Schools; and Board of Education, Lebanon Public Schools |
Attorney Jessica Ritter appeared on behalf of the respondents. Jody Waldron was granted Permission to address the matter on her own behalf. The Commissioners voted, 6-0, to amend the Hearing Officer’s Report. The Commissioners voted, 6-0, to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report as amended.* The proceedings were recorded digitally. Commissioner Shaw did not participate in this matter.
|
Joseph Luciano v. UTOPIA Assisted Living Services |
The Commissioners unanimously voted to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report.
|
Michelle Tuccitto Sullo and the New Haven Register v. Public Works Department, City of Derby; and City of Derby |
The Commissioners unanimously voted to adopt the Hearing Officer’s Report.
Tracie C. Brown reported on the Appellate Court Decision in Lamberto Lucarelli v. Freedom of Information Commission et al. dated May 29, 2012
Colleen M. Murphy reported on access-related legislation.
The meeting was adjourned at 4:11 p.m.
________________
Mary E. Schwind
*SEE ATTACHED FOR AMENDMENTS
MINREGmeeting 06132012amendedandcorrected/mes/06282012
*SEE ATTACHED FOR AMENDMENTS
MINREGmeeting 06132012amendedandcorrected/mes/06282012
AMENDMENTS
|
Elisabeth Seieroe Maurer v. Office of Corporation Counsel, City of Danbury; and City of Danbury |
Paragraph 4 of the Hearing Officer’s Report is amended as follows:
4. It is also found that on or about February 23, 2011, the respondents provided notice to the 24 individuals [or their designees] referenced in paragraphs 2[a] and 2[b], above, of the complainant’s February 16th records request. It is found that [20] 16 of the 24 individuals filed written objections to the disclosure of the records described in paragraph 2, above. The [four] EIGHT individuals who did not file objections were Robert Blantin, Thomas Burke, Richard Gerlach, Sr., [and] DOUGLAS LYLE, BRUCE MICHALEK, Michael Pascuzzi, JAMES PATTON AND JAMES PEARCE. (there remains a citation to footnote 2)
***
Footnote 2 of the Hearing Officer’s Report is amended as follows:
Footnote 2: The Commission takes note that Robert Blantin filed an objection to an earlier FOI request by the complainant in July 2010 for some of the same records. The complainant’s February 16th request, however, is more expansive and an objection has not been filed with respect to the disclosure of all the records pertaining to Mr. Blantin, which are at issue in this matter. IN ADDITION, THE COMMISSION TAKES NOTE THAT THE OBJECTIONS TO THE DISCLOSURE OF THE RECORDS PERTAINING TO THE FOLLOWING INDIVIDUALS WERE NOT FILED BY THE NAMED EMPLOYEE: BRUCE MICHALEK, JAMES PATTON AND JAMES PEARCE. ALSO, THE OBJECTION FILED ON BEHALF OF DOUGLAS LYLE WAS FILED BY BETSY LYLE, WHO IDENTIFIES HERSELF AS AN AGENT, PARENT AND GUARDIAN OF A MINOR, CHRISTOPHER LYLE.
Paragraph 24 of the Hearing Officer’s Report is amended as follows:
24. With respect to the following [164] 213 in camera records, it is found that such records pertain to Robert Blantin, Thomas Burke, DOUGLAS LYLE, BRUCE MICHALEK, Michael Pascuzzi, JAMES PATTON AND JAMES PEARCE, who did not file written objections to the disclosure of their respective records, as described in paragraph 4, above: (there remains a citation to footnote 8 and such footnote was not amended) IC-2011-370-85, IC-2011-370-86, IC-2011-370-87, IC-2011-370-89, IC-2011-370-90, IC-2011-370-91, IC-2011-370-92, IC-2011-370-93, IC-2011-370-94, IC-2011-370-96, IC-2011-370-97, IC-2011-370-98, IC-2011-370-99, IC-2011-370-100, IC-2011-370-101, IC-2011-370-102, IC-2011-370-103, IC-2011-370-105, IC-2011-370-106, IC-2011-370-147, IC-2011-370-148, IC-2011-370-150, IC-2011-370-151, IC-2011-370-152, IC-2011-370-153, IC-2011-370-154, IC-2011-370-155, IC-2011-370-156, IC-2011-370-157, IC-2011-370-158, IC-2011-370-159, IC-2011-370-161, IC-2011-370-162, IC-2011-370-163, IC-2011-370-164, IC-2011-370-165, IC-2011-370-166, IC-2011-370-167, IC-2011-370-168, IC-2011-370-171, IC-2011-370-174, IC-2011-370-176, IC-2011-370-178, IC-2011-370-179, IC-2011-370-180, IC-2011-370-182, IC-2011-370-183, IC-2011-370-185, IC-2011-370-186, IC-2011-370-188, IC-2011-370-189, IC-2011-370-190, IC-2011-370-191, IC-2011-370-192, IC-2011-370-194, IC-2011-370-195, IC-2011-370-196, IC-2011-370-197, IC-2011-370-198, IC-2011-370-199, IC-2011-370-200, IC-2011-370-201, IC-2011-370-202, IC-2011-370-203, IC-2011-370-204, IC-2011-370-205, IC-2011-370-206, IC-2011-370-207, IC-2011-370-208, IC-2011-370-209, IC-2011-370-211, IC-2011-370-212, IC-2011-370-213, IC-2011-370-216, IC-2011-370-221, IC-2011-370-224, IC-2011-370-609, IC-2011-370-610, IC-2011-370-611, IC-2011-370-612, IC-2011-370-613, IC-2011-370-615, IC-2011-370-616, IC-2011-370-617, IC-2011-370-618, IC-2011-370-620, IC-2011-370-621, IC-2011-370-622, IC-2011-370-623, IC-2011-370-624, IC-2011-370-625, IC-2011-370-626, IC-2011-370-627, IC-2011-370-628, IC-2011-370-629, IC-2011-370-630, IC-2011-370-631, IC-2011-370-632, IC-2011-370-633, IC-2011-370-634, IC-2011-370-635, IC-2011-370-636, IC-2011-370-639, IC-2011-370-640, IC-2011-370-642, IC-2011-370-643, IC-2011-370-644, IC-2011-370-646, IC-2011-370-647, IC-2011-370-648, IC-2011-370-649, IC-2011-370-650, IC-2011-370-651, IC-2011-370-652, IC-2011-370-653, IC-2011-370-654, IC-2011-370-656, IC-2011-370-657, IC-2011-370-658, IC-2011-370-659, IC-2011-370-661, IC-2011-370-662, IC-2011-370-665, IC-2011-370-666, IC-2011-370-668, IC-2011-370-669, IC-2011-370-670, IC-2011-370-671, IC-2011-370-672, IC-2011-370-673, IC-2011-370-674, IC-2011-370-675, IC-2011-370-676, IC-2011-370-677, IC-2011-370-678, IC-2011-370-679, IC-2011-370-680, IC-2011-370-681, IC-2011-370-682, IC-2011-370-683, IC-2011-370-684, IC-2011-370-685, IC-2011-370-687, IC-2011-370-690, IC-2011-370-691, IC-2011-370-692, IC-2011-370-693, IC-2011-370-694, IC-2011-370-695, IC-2011-370-697, IC-2011-370-698, IC-2011-370-699, IC-2011-370-701, IC-2011-370-702, IC-2011-370-708, IC-2011-370-709, IC-2011-370-710, IC-2011-370-711, IC-2011-370-713, IC-2011-370-718, IC-2011-370-719, IC-2011-370-720, IC-2011-370-721, IC-2011-370-722, IC-2011-370-728, IC-2011-370-729, IC-2011-370-979, IC-2011-370-980, IC-2011-370-981, IC-2011-370-982, IC-2011-370-983, IC-2011-370-984, IC-2011-370-985, IC-2011-370-986, IC-2011-370-987, IC-2011-370-989, IC-2011-370-990, IC-2011-370-991, IC-2011-370-992, IC-2011-370-993, IC-2011-370-994, IC-2011-370-995, IC-2011-370-996, IC-2011-370-997, IC-2011-370-1000, IC-2011-370-1001, IC-2011-370-1002, IC-2011-370-1003, IC-2011-370-1006, IC-2011-370-1008, IC-2011-370-1009, IC-2011-370-1010, IC-2011-370-1011, IC-2011-370-1012, IC-2011-370-1014, IC-2011-370-1015, IC-2011-370-1016, IC-2011-370-1019, IC-2011-370-1020, IC-2011-370-1021, IC-2011-370-1022, IC-2011-370-1023, IC-2011-370-1024, IC-2011-370-1028, IC-2011-370-1029, IC-2011-370-1031, IC-2011-370-1032, IC-2011-370-1033, IC-2011-370-1035, IC-2011-370-1036, IC-2011-370-1037, IC-2011-370-1038, IC-2011-370-1039, IC-2011-370-1418 and IC-2011-370-1419.
Paragraph 29 of the Hearing Officer’s Report is amended as follows:
29. With respect to the disclosure of the records described in paragraphs 27[a] and 27[b],
above, it is found that disclosure of the following in camera records, in their entirety, would constitute an invasion of privacy because the information contained in such records does not pertain to legitimate matters of public concern, and the disclosure of such information would be highly offensive to a reasonable person: IC-2011-370-556, IC-2011-370-745, IC-2011-370-776 [, IC-2011-370-1028] and IC-2011-370-1481 through IC-2011-370-1482.
above, it is found that disclosure of the following in camera records, in their entirety, would constitute an invasion of privacy because the information contained in such records does not pertain to legitimate matters of public concern, and the disclosure of such information would be highly offensive to a reasonable person: IC-2011-370-556, IC-2011-370-745, IC-2011-370-776 [, IC-2011-370-1028] and IC-2011-370-1481 through IC-2011-370-1482.
Endnote 4 is amended as follows:
4. ACCIDENT & INJURY REPORTS and INVESTIGATIONS:
IC-2011-370-1, IC-2011-370-2, IC-2011-370-3, IC-2011-370-4, IC-2011-370-19, IC-2011-370-20, IC-2011-370-28, IC-2011-370-29, IC-2011-370-30, IC-2011-370-36, IC-2011-370-37, IC-2011-370-68, IC-2011-370-107, IC-2011-370-108, IC-2011-370-109, IC-2011-370-110, IC-2011-370-111, IC-2011-370-112, IC-2011-370-113, IC-2011-370-114, IC-2011-370-115, IC-2011-370-116, IC-2011-370-117, IC-2011-370-118, IC-2011-370-121, IC-2011-370-122, IC-2011-370-123, IC-2011-370-124, IC-2011-370-127, IC-2011-370-128, IC-2011-370-129, IC-2011-370-130, IC-2011-370-132, IC-2011-370-133, IC-2011-370-134, IC-2011-370-136, IC-2011-370-137, IC-2011-370-139, IC-2011-370-140, IC-2011-370-141, IC-2011-370-142, IC-2011-370-143, IC-2011-370-144, IC-2011-370-145, IC-2011-370-146, IC-2011-370-228, IC-2011-370-229, IC-2011-370-230, IC-2011-370-231, IC-2011-370-232, IC-2011-370-233, IC-2011-370-267, IC-2011-370-268, IC-2011-370-281, IC-2011-370-282, IC-2011-370-283, IC-2011-370-284, IC-2011-370-285, IC-2011-370-286, IC-2011-370-287, IC-2011-370-290, IC-2011-370-291, IC-2011-370-292, IC-2011-370-295, IC-2011-370-296, IC-2011-370-297, IC-2011-370-298, IC-2011-370-299, IC-2011-370-300, IC-2011-370-301, IC-2011-370-302, IC-2011-370-306, IC-2011-370-307, IC-2011-370-309, IC-2011-370-310, IC-2011-370-314, IC-2011-370-315, IC-2011-370-317, IC-2011-370-318, IC-2011-370-321, IC-2011-370-322, IC-2011-370-326, IC-2011-370-327, IC-2011-370-328, IC-2011-370-329, IC-2011-370-335, IC-2011-370-338, IC-2011-370-343, IC-2011-370-344, IC-2011-370-345, IC-2011-370-346, IC-2011-370-350, IC-2011-370-379, IC-2011-370-380, IC-2011-370-381, IC-2011-370-383, IC-2011-370-389, IC-2011-370-390, IC-2011-370-394, IC-2011-370-395, IC-2011-370-401, IC-2011-370-402, IC-2011-370-403, IC-2011-370-404, IC-2011-370-414, IC-2011-370-415, IC-2011-370-418, IC-2011-370-419, IC-2011-370-424, IC-2011-370-425, IC-2011-370-429, IC-2011-370-468, IC-2011-370-469, IC-2011-370-470, IC-2011-370-471, IC-2011-370-472, IC-2011-370-474, IC-2011-370-477, IC-2011-370-478, IC-2011-370-479, IC-2011-370-480, IC-2011-370-481, IC-2011-370-484, IC-2011-370-485, IC-2011-370-491, IC-2011-370-492, IC-2011-370-496, IC-2011-370-497, IC-2011-370-527, IC-2011-370-531, IC-2011-370-532, IC-2011-370-544, IC-2011-370-545, IC-2011-370-731, IC-2011-370-732, IC-2011-370-733, IC-2011-370-734, IC-2011-370-735, IC-2011-370-736, IC-2011-370-737, IC-2011-370-742, IC-2011-370-743, IC-2011-370-750, IC-2011-370-751, IC-2011-370-752, IC-2011-370-753, IC-2011-370-760, IC-2011-370-761, IC-2011-370-762, IC-2011-370-796, IC-2011-370-797, IC-2011-370-800, IC-2011-370-801, IC-2011-370-802, IC-2011-370-803, IC-2011-370-806, IC-2011-370-807, IC-2011-370-808, IC-2011-370-809, IC-2011-370-810, IC-2011-370-811, IC-2011-370-812, IC-2011-370-813, IC-2011-370-816, IC-2011-370-817, IC-2011-370-819, IC-2011-370-820, IC-2011-370-821, IC-2011-370-822, IC-2011-370-823, IC-2011-370-824, IC-2011-370-827, IC-2011-370-828, IC-2011-370-829, IC-2011-370-830, IC-2011-370-831, IC-2011-370-832, IC-2011-370-833, IC-2011-370-834, IC-2011-370-836, IC-2011-370-837, IC-2011-370-838, IC-2011-370-839, IC-2011-370-843, IC-2011-370-844, IC-2011-370-845, IC-2011-370-846, IC-2011-370-847, IC-2011-370-848, IC-2011-370-849, IC-2011-370-850, IC-2011-370-851, IC-2011-370-852, IC-2011-370-854, IC-2011-370-857, IC-2011-370-863, IC-2011-370-864, IC-2011-370-865, IC-2011-370-866, IC-2011-370-867, IC-2011-370-868, IC-2011-370-880, IC-2011-370-886, IC-2011-370-887, IC-2011-370-891, IC-2011-370-902, IC-2011-370-903, IC-2011-370-904, IC-2011-370-905, IC-2011-370-907, IC-2011-370-908, IC-2011-370-909, IC-2011-370-913, IC-2011-370-923, IC-2011-370-949, IC-2011-370-950, IC-2011-370-951, IC-2011-370-961, IC-2011-370-962, [IC-2011-370-979, IC-2011-370-980, IC-2011-370-984, IC-2011-370-985, IC-2011-370-986, IC-2011-370-987, IC-2011-370-1000, IC-2011-370-1001, IC-2011-370-1002, IC-2011-370-1003, IC-2011-370-1006, IC-2011-370-1008, IC-2011-370-1010, IC-2011-370-1012, IC-2011-370-1014, IC-2011-370-1021, IC-2011-370-1022, IC-2011-370-1023, IC-2011-370-1024, IC-2011-370-1031, IC-2011-370-1032, IC-2011-370-1033, IC-2011-370-1036, IC-2011-370-1037, IC-2011-370-1038, IC-2011-370-1039,] IC-2011-370-1040, IC-2011-370-1041, IC-2011-370-1042, IC-2011-370-1043, IC-2011-370-1044, IC-2011-370-1045, IC-2011-370-1048, IC-2011-370-1050, IC-2011-370-1051, IC-2011-370-1053, IC-2011-370-1054, IC-2011-370-1063, IC-2011-370-1064, IC-2011-370-1065, IC-2011-370-1066, IC-2011-370-1070, IC-2011-370-1071, IC-2011-370-1076, IC-2011-370-1077, IC-2011-370-1079, IC-2011-370-1083, IC-2011-370-1084, IC-2011-370-1085, IC-2011-370-1086, IC-2011-370-1089, IC-2011-370-1090, IC-2011-370-1096, IC-2011-370-1097, IC-2011-370-1098, IC-2011-370-1099, IC-2011-370-1100, IC-2011-370-1101, IC-2011-370-1103, IC-2011-370-1104, IC-2011-370-1107, IC-2011-370-1113, IC-2011-370-1137, IC-2011-370-1138, IC-2011-370-1146, IC-2011-370-1148, IC-2011-370-1162, IC-2011-370-1163, IC-2011-370-1203, IC-2011-370-1204, IC-2011-370-1205, IC-2011-370-1206, IC-2011-370-1207, IC-2011-370-1208, IC-2011-370-1226, IC-2011-370-1227, IC-2011-370-1230, IC-2011-370-1231, IC-2011-370-1232, IC-2011-370-1242, IC-2011-370-1243, IC-2011-370-1246, IC-2011-370-1247, IC-2011-370-1248, IC-2011-370-1254, IC-2011-370-1255, IC-2011-370-1262, IC-2011-370-1263, IC-2011-370-1264, IC-2011-370-1269, IC-2011-370-1276, IC-2011-370-1277, IC-2011-370-1287, IC-2011-370-1288, IC-2011-370-1291, IC-2011-370-1292, IC-2011-370-1301, IC-2011-370-1302, IC-2011-370-1308, IC-2011-370-1309, IC-2011-370-1316, IC-2011-370-1317, IC-2011-370-1318, IC-2011-370-1325, IC-2011-370-1334, IC-2011-370-1335, IC-2011-370-1339, IC-2011-370-1340, IC-2011-370-1348, IC-2011-370-1349, IC-2011-370-1365, IC-2011-370-1366, IC-2011-370-1367, IC-2011-370-1368, IC-2011-370-1369, [IC-2011-370-1418, IC-2011-370-1419,] IC-2011-370-1420, IC-2011-370-1421, IC-2011-370-1422, IC-2011-370-1423, IC-2011-370-1424, IC-2011-370-1425, IC-2011-370-1426, IC-2011-370-1427, IC-2011-370-1428, IC-2011-370-1429, IC-2011-370-1430, IC-2011-370-1431, IC-2011-370-1432, IC-2011-370-1433, IC-2011-370-1434, IC-2011-370-1435, IC-2011-370-1436, IC-2011-370-1438, IC-2011-370-1439, IC-2011-370-1440, IC-2011-370-1441, IC-2011-370-1442, IC-2011-370-1444, IC-2011-370-1445, IC-2011-370-1446, IC-2011-370-1447, IC-2011-370-1448, IC-2011-370-1455, IC-2011-370-1456, IC-2011-370-1457, IC-2011-370-1458, IC-2011-370-1459, IC-2011-370-1461, IC-2011-370-1462, IC-2011-370-1463, IC-2011-370-1464, IC-2011-370-1465, IC-2011-370-1466, IC-2011-370-1470, IC-2011-370-1471, IC-2011-370-1472, IC-2011-370-1474, IC-2011-370-1475, IC-2011-370-1476, IC-2011-370-1477, IC-2011-370-1478, IC-2011-370-1479, IC-2011-370-1480, IC-2011-370-1483, IC-2011-370-1484, IC-2011-370-1486, IC-2011-370-1487, IC-2011-370-1494, IC-2011-370-1495, IC-2011-370-1496, IC-2011-370-1504, IC-2011-370-1505, IC-2011-370-1510, IC-2011-370-1511, IC-2011-370-1512, IC-2011-370-1513, IC-2011-370-1514, IC-2011-370-1515, IC-2011-370-1516, IC-2011-370-1518, IC-2011-370-1519, IC-2011-370-1520, IC-2011-370-1521, IC-2011-370-1522, IC-2011-370-1523, IC-2011-370-1524, IC-2011-370-1525, IC-2011-370-1527, IC-2011-370-1528, IC-2011-370-1529, IC-2011-370-1530, IC-2011-370-1533, IC-2011-370-1534, IC-2011-370-1536, IC-2011-370-1537, IC-2011-370-1540, IC-2011-370-1541, IC-2011-370-1542, IC-2011-370-1543, IC-2011-370-1544, IC-2011-370-1549, IC-2011-370-1550, IC-2011-370-1552, IC-2011-370-1553, IC-2011-370-1555, IC-2011-370-1556, IC-2011-370-1557, IC-2011-370-1558, IC-2011-370-1561, IC-2011-370-1562, IC-2011-370-1566, IC-2011-370-1567, IC-2011-370-1568, IC-2011-370-1569, IC-2011-370-1571, IC-2011-370-1572, IC-2011-370-1573, IC-2011-370-1574, IC-2011-370-1575, IC-2011-370-1576, IC-2011-370-1577, IC-2011-370-1578, IC-2011-370-1581, IC-2011-370-1582, IC-2011-370-1593, IC-2011-370-1595, IC-2011-370-1597, IC-2011-370-1598, IC-2011-370-1610, IC-2011-370-1611, IC-2011-370-1616, IC-2011-370-1617, IC-2011-370-1621, IC-2011-370-1622, IC-2011-370-1623, IC-2011-370-1631, IC-2011-370-1632, IC-2011-370-1647, IC-2011-370-1649, IC-2011-370-1654, IC-2011-370-1670, IC-2011-370-1671, IC-2011-370-1672, IC-2011-370-1673, IC-2011-370-1674, IC-2011-370-1675, IC-2011-370-1676, IC-2011-370-1681, IC-2011-370-1682, IC-2011-370-1685, IC-2011-370-1686, IC-2011-370-1687, IC-2011-370-1688, IC-2011-370-1692, IC-2011-370-1693, IC-2011-370-1703, IC-2011-370-1704, IC-2011-370-1720, IC-2011-370-1721, IC-2011-370-1723, IC-2011-370-1724, IC-2011-370-1731, IC-2011-370-1732, IC-2011-370-1756, IC-2011-370-1757, IC-2011-370-1771, IC-2011-370-1772, IC-2011-370-1775, IC-2011-370-1776, IC-2011-370-1777, IC-2011-370-1778, IC-2011-370-1787, IC-2011-370-1790, IC-2011-370-1792, IC-2011-370-1800, IC-2011-370-1801, IC-2011-370-1802, IC-2011-370-1806, IC-2011-370-1807, IC-2011-370-1808, IC-2011-370-1809, IC-2011-370-1817, IC-2011-370-1818, IC-2011-370-1820, IC-2011-370-1822, IC-2011-370-1830, IC-2011-370-1831, IC-2011-370-1839, IC-2011-370-1842, IC-2011-370-1844, IC-2011-370-1846, IC-2011-370-1853, IC-2011-370-1854, IC-2011-370-1855, IC-2011-370-1856, IC-2011-370-1857, IC-2011-370-1860 and IC-2011-370-1861.
Endnote 5 is amended as follows:
5. RETURN TO WORK NOTICES, VERIFICATION OF DISABILITY NOTICES and ABSENCE RECORDS:
IC-2011-370-6, IC-2011-370-12, IC-2011-370-13, IC-2011-370-16, IC-2011-370-21, IC-2011-370-22, IC-2011-370-32, IC-2011-370-34, IC-2011-370-38, IC-2011-370-54, IC-2011-370-57, IC-2011-370-59, IC-2011-370-63, IC-2011-370-82, IC-2011-370-131, IC-2011-370-235, IC-2011-370-237, IC-2011-370-239, IC-2011-370-241, IC-2011-370-243, IC-2011-370-244, IC-2011-370-250, IC-2011-370-251, IC-2011-370-253, IC-2011-370-254, IC-2011-370-256, IC-2011-370-257, IC-2011-370-258, IC-2011-370-260, IC-2011-370-262, IC-2011-370-264, IC-2011-370-269, IC-2011-370-270, IC-2011-370-272, IC-2011-370-275, IC-2011-370-278, IC-2011-370-294, IC-2011-370-313, IC-2011-370-316, IC-2011-370-319, IC-2011-370-332, IC-2011-370-336, IC-2011-370-351, IC-2011-370-358, IC-2011-370-384, IC-2011-370-397, IC-2011-370-399, IC-2011-370-400, IC-2011-370-408, IC-2011-370-411, IC-2011-370-412, IC-2011-370-416, IC-2011-370-420, IC-2011-370-427, IC-2011-370-428, IC-2011-370-433, IC-2011-370-435, IC-2011-370-482, IC-2011-370-487, IC-2011-370-495, IC-2011-370-500, IC-2011-370-501, IC-2011-370-505, IC-2011-370-507, IC-2011-370-508, IC-2011-370-510, IC-2011-370-513, IC-2011-370-521, IC-2011-370-522, IC-2011-370-530, IC-2011-370-534, IC-2011-370-548, IC-2011-370-550, IC-2011-370-551, IC-2011-370-561, IC-2011-370-562, IC-2011-370-563, IC-2011-370-567, IC-2011-370-569, IC-2011-370-570, IC-2011-370-571, IC-2011-370-573, IC-2011-370-575, IC-2011-370-577, IC-2011-370-579, IC-2011-370-584, IC-2011-370-744, IC-2011-370-755, IC-2011-370-756, IC-2011-370-758, IC-2011-370-763, IC-2011-370-766, IC-2011-370-767, IC-2011-370-768, IC-2011-370-778, IC-2011-370-826, IC-2011-370-841, IC-2011-370-856, IC-2011-370-859, IC-2011-370-869, IC-2011-370-872, IC-2011-370-882, IC-2011-370-890, IC-2011-370-892, IC-2011-370-894, IC-2011-370-901, IC-2011-370-906, IC-2011-370-910, IC-2011-370-916, IC-2011-370-918, IC-2011-370-952, IC-2011-370-954, IC-2011-370-958, IC-2011-370-959, IC-2011-370-965, [IC-2011-370-982, IC-2011-370-989, IC-2011-370-990, IC-2011-370-991, IC-2011-370-992, IC-2011-370-1009, IC-2011-370-1015, IC-2011-370-1016, IC-2011-370-1020, IC-2011-370-1029, IC-2011-370-1035,] IC-2011-370-1049, IC-2011-370-1055, IC-2011-370-1068, IC-2011-370-1074, IC-2011-370-1080, IC-2011-370-1081, IC-2011-370-1087, IC-2011-370-1105, IC-2011-370-1108, IC-2011-370-1109, IC-2011-370-1116, IC-2011-370-1117, IC-2011-370-1120, IC-2011-370-1121, IC-2011-370-1122, IC-2011-370-1124, IC-2011-370-1126, IC-2011-370-1127, IC-2011-370-1129, IC-2011-370-1130, IC-2011-370-1132, IC-2011-370-1133, IC-2011-370-1141, IC-2011-370-1147, IC-2011-370-1154, IC-2011-370-1157, IC-2011-370-1158, IC-2011-370-1161, IC-2011-370-1167, IC-2011-370-1170, IC-2011-370-1174, IC-2011-370-1178, IC-2011-370-1179, IC-2011-370-1180, IC-2011-370-1182, IC-2011-370-1183, IC-2011-370-1187, IC-2011-370-1209, IC-2011-370-1210, IC-2011-370-1249, IC-2011-370-1258, IC-2011-370-1260, IC-2011-370-1261, IC-2011-370-1266, IC-2011-370-1267, IC-2011-370-1273, IC-2011-370-1283, IC-2011-370-1284, IC-2011-370-1289, IC-2011-370-1299, IC-2011-370-1303, IC-2011-370-1304, IC-2011-370-1307, IC-2011-370-1319, IC-2011-370-1330, IC-2011-370-1337, IC-2011-370-1341, IC-2011-370-1345, IC-2011-370-1347, IC-2011-370-1354, IC-2011-370-1359, IC-2011-370-1361, IC-2011-370-1362, IC-2011-370-1372, IC-2011-370-1373, IC-2011-370-1374, IC-2011-370-1375, IC-2011-370-1376, IC-2011-370-1377, IC-2011-370-1379, IC-2011-370-1384, IC-2011-370-1387, IC-2011-370-1388, IC-2011-370-1414, IC-2011-370-1468, IC-2011-370-1473, IC-2011-370-1493, IC-2011-370-1500, IC-2011-370-1501, IC-2011-370-1503, IC-2011-370-1532, IC-2011-370-1535, IC-2011-370-1545, IC-2011-370-1554, IC-2011-370-1559, IC-2011-370-1563, IC-2011-370-1591, IC-2011-370-1602, IC-2011-370-1604, IC-2011-370-1606, IC-2011-370-1607, IC-2011-370-1609, IC-2011-370-1612, IC-2011-370-1613, IC-2011-370-1615, IC-2011-370-1620, IC-2011-370-1625, IC-2011-370-1627, IC-2011-370-1628, IC-2011-370-1636, IC-2011-370-1637, IC-2011-370-1639, IC-2011-370-1645, IC-2011-370-1646, IC-2011-370-1653, IC-2011-370-1677, IC-2011-370-1678, IC-2011-370-1684, IC-2011-370-1689, IC-2011-370-1700, IC-2011-370-1701, IC-2011-370-1708, IC-2011-370-1709, IC-2011-370-1710, IC-2011-370-1712, IC-2011-370-1713, IC-2011-370-1715, IC-2011-370-1716, IC-2011-370-1717, IC-2011-370-1725, IC-2011-370-1726, IC-2011-370-1729, IC-2011-370-1730, IC-2011-370-1737, IC-2011-370-1738, IC-2011-370-1741, IC-2011-370-1743, IC-2011-370-1744, IC-2011-370-1753, IC-2011-370-1754, IC-2011-370-1760, IC-2011-370-1761, IC-2011-370-1762, IC-2011-370-1763, IC-2011-370-1765, IC-2011-370-1766, IC-2011-370-1768, IC-2011-370-1769, IC-2011-370-1773, IC-2011-370-1780, IC-2011-370-1783, IC-2011-370-1784, IC-2011-370-1786, IC-2011-370-1789, IC-2011-370-1794, IC-2011-370-1797, IC-2011-370-1799, IC-2011-370-1805, IC-2011-370-1812, IC-2011-370-1814, IC-2011-370-1815, IC-2011-370-1821, IC-2011-370-1837, IC-2011-370-1840, IC-2011-370-1841, IC-2011-370-1848, IC-2011-370-1863, IC-2011-370-1865, IC-2011-370-1869, IC-2011-370-1871, IC-2011-370-1872 and IC-2011-370-1873. [there remains a citation to footnote 9 and the substance of the footnote has not been amended]
Endnote 6 is amended as follows:
6. EXCUSED ABSENCES, FIT & UNFIT FOR DUTY NOTIFICATIONS, WORK CAPACITY REPORTS and CERTIFICATES OF CARE (disclose records in their entirety):
IC-2011-370-8, IC-2011-370-9, IC-2011-370-17, IC-2011-370-33, IC-2011-370-41, IC-2011-370-42, IC-2011-370-44, IC-2011-370-45, IC-2011-370-46, IC-2011-370-47, IC-2011-370-48, IC-2011-370-49, IC-2011-370-52, IC-2011-370-61, IC-2011-370-80, IC-2011-370-83, IC-2011-370-126, IC-2011-370-135, IC-2011-370-238, IC-2011-370-240, IC-2011-370-242, IC-2011-370-245, IC-2011-370-246, IC-2011-370-247, IC-2011-370-248, IC-2011-370-249, IC-2011-370-252, IC-2011-370-271, IC-2011-370-273, IC-2011-370-274, IC-2011-370-276, IC-2011-370-277, IC-2011-370-279, IC-2011-370-280, IC-2011-370-304, IC-2011-370-312, IC-2011-370-333, IC-2011-370-334, IC-2011-370-349, IC-2011-370-353, IC-2011-370-354, IC-2011-370-355, IC-2011-370-357, IC-2011-370-359, IC-2011-370-363, IC-2011-370-378, IC-2011-370-385, IC-2011-370-386, IC-2011-370-387, IC-2011-370- 396, IC-2011-370-398, IC-2011-370-409, IC-2011-370-410, IC-2011-370-417, IC-2011-370-421, IC-2011-370-422, IC-2011-370-423, IC-2011-370-426, IC-2011-370-432, IC-2011-370-434, IC-2011-370-436, IC-2011-370-438, IC-2011-370-486, IC-2011-370-489, IC-2011-370-490, IC-2011-370-499, IC-2011-370-504, IC-2011-370-506, IC-2011-370-511, IC-2011-370-514, IC-2011-370-516, IC-2011-370-517, IC-2011-370-519, IC-2011-370-520, IC-2011-370-523, IC-2011-370-546, IC-2011-370-547, IC-2011-370-549, IC-2011-370-558, IC-2011-370-559, IC-2011-370-565, IC-2011-370-566, IC-2011-370-568, IC-2011-370-572, IC-2011-370-580, IC-2011-370-582, IC-2011-370-586, IC-2011-370-589, IC-2011-370-759, IC-2011-370-769, IC-2011-370-771, IC-2011-370-773, IC-2011-370-774, IC-2011-370-775, IC-2011-370-777, IC-2011-370-779, IC-2011-370-786, IC-2011-370-788, IC-2011-370-798, IC-2011-370-799, IC-2011-370-840, IC-2011-370-842, IC-2011-370-855, IC-2011-370-860, IC-2011-370-861, IC-2011-370-862, IC-2011-370-881, IC-2011-370-883, IC-2011-370-884, IC-2011-370-885, IC-2011-370-893, IC-2011-370-896, IC-2011-370-914, IC-2011-370-917, IC-2011-370-957, IC-2011-370-960, IC-2011-370-969, [IC-2011-370-981, IC-2011-370-993, IC-2011-370-994, IC-2011-370-995, IC-2011-370-996, IC-2011-370-997, IC-2011-370-1019,] IC-2011-370-1057, IC-2011-370-1059, IC-2011-370-1062, IC-2011-370-1067, IC-2011-370-1073, IC-2011-370-1075, IC-2011-370-1082, IC-2011-370-1088, IC-2011-370-1091, IC-2011-370-1092, IC-2011-370-1093, IC-2011-370-1094, IC-2011-370-1095, IC-2011-370-1106, IC-2011-370-1110, IC-2011-370-1111, IC-2011-370-1114, IC-2011-370-1118, IC-2011-370-1119, IC-2011-370-1125, IC-2011-370-1131, IC-2011-370-1134, I IC-2011-370-1135, C-2011-370-1136, IC-2011-370-1152, IC-2011-370-1155, IC-2011-370-1156, IC-2011-370-1159, IC-2011-370-1160, IC-2011-370-1166, IC-2011-370-1168, IC-2011-370-1184, IC-2011-370-1185, IC-2011-370-1220, IC-2011-370-1221, IC-2011-370-1223, IC-2011-370-1225, IC-2011-370-1233, IC-2011-370-1235, IC-2011-370-1239, IC-2011-370-1240, IC-2011-370-1241, IC-2011-370-1244, IC-2011-370-1250, IC-2011-370-1257, IC-2011-370-1274, IC-2011-370-1281, IC-2011-370-1294, IC-2011-370-1298, IC-2011-370-1300, IC-2011-370-1310, IC-2011-370-1312, IC-2011-370-1315, IC-2011-370-1331, IC-2011-370-1332, IC-2011-370-1333, IC-2011-370-1338, IC-2011-370-1344, IC-2011-370-1346, IC-2011-370-1355, IC-2011-370-1360, IC-2011-370-1363, IC-2011-370-1364, IC-2011-370-1385, IC-2011-370-1386, IC-2011-370-1389, IC-2011-370-1390, IC-2011-370-1391, IC-2011-370-1392, IC-2011-370-1394, IC-2011-370-1407, IC-2011-370-1411, IC-2011-370-1416, IC-2011-370-1417, IC-2011-370-1437, IC-2011-370-1449, IC-2011-370-1452, IC-2011-370-1454, IC-2011-370-1460, IC-2011-370-1469, IC-2011-370-1492, IC-2011-370-1499, IC-2011-370-1502, IC-2011-370-1507, IC-2011-370-1539, IC-2011-370-1548, IC-2011-370-1570, IC-2011-370-1592, IC-2011-370-1599, IC-2011-370-1600, IC-2011-370-1601, IC-2011-370-1603, IC-2011-370-1605, IC-2011-370-1614, IC-2011-370-1638, IC-2011-370-1640, IC-2011-370-1641, IC-2011-370-1643, IC-2011-370-1651, IC-2011-370-1652, IC-2011-370-1656, IC-2011-370-1705, IC-2011-370-1706, IC-2011-370-1707, IC-2011-370-1711, IC-2011-370-1714, IC-2011-370-1718, IC-2011-370-1727, IC-2011-370-1733, IC-2011-370-1739, IC-2011-370-1740, IC-2011-370-1755, IC-2011-370-1758, IC-2011-370-1767, IC-2011-370-1770, IC-2011-370-1774, IC-2011-370-1782, IC-2011-370-1796, IC-2011-370-1798, IC-2011-370-1862, IC-2011-370-1864, IC-2011-370-1866, IC-2011-370-1867, IC-2011-370-1868, IC-2011-370-1870, IC-2011-370-1874 and IC-2011-370-1875. [there remains a citation to footnote 10 and the substance of the footnote has not been amended]
Endnote 7 is amended as follows:
7. EXCUSED ABSENCES, FIT & UNFIT FOR DUTY NOTIFICATIONS, WORK CAPACITY REPORTS and CERTIFICATES OF CARE (disclose with redactions):
IC-2011-370-7, IC-2011-370-43, IC-2011-370-50, IC-2011-370-51, IC-2011-370-53, IC-2011-370-56, IC-2011-370-58, IC-2011-370-60, IC-2011-370-62, IC-2011-370-65, IC-2011-370-84, IC-2011-370-305, IC-2011-370-330, IC-2011-370-331, IC-2011-370-356, IC-2011-370-362, IC-2011-370-407, IC-2011-370-439, IC-2011-370-483, IC-2011-370-488, IC-2011-370-509, IC-2011-370-512, IC-2011-370-518, IC-2011-370-557, IC-2011-370-560, IC-2011-370-564, IC-2011-370-574, IC-2011-370-578, IC-2011-370-583, IC-2011-370-585, IC-2011-370-597, IC-2011-370-770, IC-2011-370-953, IC-2011-370-964, [IC-2011-370-983, IC-2011-370-1011], IC-2011-370-1153, IC-2011-370-1165, IC-2011-370-1177, IC-2011-370-1181, IC-2011-370-1186, IC-2011-370-1188, IC-2011-370-1234, IC-2011-370-1236, IC-2011-370-1253, IC-2011-370-1280, IC-2011-370-1342, IC-2011-370-1353, IC-2011-370-1381, IC-2011-370-1382, IC-2011-370-1383, IC-2011-370-1450, IC-2011-370-1451, IC-2011-370-1508, IC-2011-370-1642, IC-2011-370-1644, IC-2011-370-1648, IC-2011-370-1650, IC-2011-370-1734, IC-2011-370-1736, IC-2011-370-1779, IC-2011-370-1781, IC-2011-370-1785, IC-2011-370-1788, IC-2011-370-1791, IC-2011-370-1793, IC-2011-370-1795, IC-2011-370-1810, IC-2011-370-1811, IC-2011-370-1813, IC-2011-370-1816, IC-2011-370-1819, IC-2011-370-1832, IC-2011-370-1838, IC-2011-370-1843, IC-2011-370-1845, IC-2011-370-1847, IC-2011-370-1849, IC-2011-370-1852 and IC-2011-370-1876.
IC-2011-370-7, IC-2011-370-43, IC-2011-370-50, IC-2011-370-51, IC-2011-370-53, IC-2011-370-56, IC-2011-370-58, IC-2011-370-60, IC-2011-370-62, IC-2011-370-65, IC-2011-370-84, IC-2011-370-305, IC-2011-370-330, IC-2011-370-331, IC-2011-370-356, IC-2011-370-362, IC-2011-370-407, IC-2011-370-439, IC-2011-370-483, IC-2011-370-488, IC-2011-370-509, IC-2011-370-512, IC-2011-370-518, IC-2011-370-557, IC-2011-370-560, IC-2011-370-564, IC-2011-370-574, IC-2011-370-578, IC-2011-370-583, IC-2011-370-585, IC-2011-370-597, IC-2011-370-770, IC-2011-370-953, IC-2011-370-964, [IC-2011-370-983, IC-2011-370-1011], IC-2011-370-1153, IC-2011-370-1165, IC-2011-370-1177, IC-2011-370-1181, IC-2011-370-1186, IC-2011-370-1188, IC-2011-370-1234, IC-2011-370-1236, IC-2011-370-1253, IC-2011-370-1280, IC-2011-370-1342, IC-2011-370-1353, IC-2011-370-1381, IC-2011-370-1382, IC-2011-370-1383, IC-2011-370-1450, IC-2011-370-1451, IC-2011-370-1508, IC-2011-370-1642, IC-2011-370-1644, IC-2011-370-1648, IC-2011-370-1650, IC-2011-370-1734, IC-2011-370-1736, IC-2011-370-1779, IC-2011-370-1781, IC-2011-370-1785, IC-2011-370-1788, IC-2011-370-1791, IC-2011-370-1793, IC-2011-370-1795, IC-2011-370-1810, IC-2011-370-1811, IC-2011-370-1813, IC-2011-370-1816, IC-2011-370-1819, IC-2011-370-1832, IC-2011-370-1838, IC-2011-370-1843, IC-2011-370-1845, IC-2011-370-1847, IC-2011-370-1849, IC-2011-370-1852 and IC-2011-370-1876.
|
George Schober v. Janet Tyler, Superintendent, Lebanon Public Schools; and Board of Education, Lebanon Public Schools |
The Hearing Officer’s Report is amended as follows:
30. IT IS CONCLUDED, THEREFORE, THAT THE RESPONDENTS DID NOT VIOLATE THE FOI ACT AS ALLEGED BY THE COMPLAINANT IN PARAGRAPHS 2B, ABOVE.
31. [30.] WITH RESPECT TO THE COMPLAINANT’S SEPTEMBER 6, 2011 REQUEST, [Furthermore,] it is found that while the respondent superintendent provided the instructions described in paragraph 12, above, it is found that it was not her intention to delay compliance with a request for a copy of only two pages. It is found that the complainant scheduled his visit to the respondent superintendent’s office on the second day of school – just one business day after power had been restored to the area. It is found that the respondent superintendent anticipated that the complainant would request volumes of copies on one of the busiest days of the school year. It is found that it was reasonable for her to try to manage the work load that she reasonably anticipated her staff would be under on that day. The respondent superintendent testified, and it is found, that had she been in the office at that time, she would have provided the complainant with a copy of the
requested record.
requested record.
[31. It is found that, while the administrative assistant showed a regrettable lack of judgment, it would not be in the interest of fairness to hold the respondents accountable in this regard.]
[32. It is concluded, therefore, that the respondents did not violate the FOI Act as alleged by the complainant in paragraphs 2b and 2c, above.]
32. NONETHELESS, IT IS FOUND THAT COMPLIANCE WITH THE COMPLAINANT’S SEPTEMBER 6, 2011 REQUEST FOR A COPY OF JUST TWO PAGES WAS NOT PROMPT WITHIN THE MEANING OF §§1-210(A) AND 1-212(A), G.S.
33. IT IS ALSO FOUND THAT IT WAS THE RESPONDENT SUPERINTENDENT’S INSTRUCTIONS THAT PRECLUDED PROMPT COMPLIANCE WITH THE COMPLAINANT’S SEPTEMBER 6, 2011 REQUEST AND THAT HER INSTRUCTIONS SHOULD HAVE INCLUDED THE FACTORS FOUND IN ADVISORY OPINION #51 AS DESCRIBED IN PARAGRAPHS 21 AND 22, ABOVE.
34. CONSEQUENTLY, IT IS FOUND THAT THE RESPONDENTS VIOLATED THE DISCLOSURE PROVISIONS OF §§1-210(A) AND 1-212(A), G.S., BY FAILING TO PROMPTLY COMPLY WITH THE COMPLAINANT’S SEPTEMBER 6, 2011 REQUEST.
35. The Commission declines to consider the complainant’s request for the imposition of a civil penalty.
The following order by the Commission is hereby recommended on the basis of the record concerning the above-captioned complaint:
1. [Henceforth, the respondents shall strictly comply with the notice provisions of §1-225(d), G.S.] HENCEFORTH, THE RESPONDENTS SHALL STRICTLY COMPLY WITH THE PROVISIONS OF §§1-210 AND 1-212, G.S., THAT REQUIRE PROMPT DISCLOSURE OF PUBLIC RECORDS AND THE NOTICE PROVISIONS OF §1-225(D), G.S.
2. The Commission notes that the respondents agreed to allow the complainant access to inspect the records responsive to his amended request as described in paragraph 19 of the findings, above.